Learn
Learn
Close

They Ask, You Answer

A revolutionary approach to inbound sales, content marketing, and today’s digital consumer.

Learn MoreLearn More

Free Courses in IMPACT+

Dozens of sales, marketing, and content courses inside IMPACT+. Start learning now.

See all coursesSee all courses
Events
Events
Close
IMPACT+ Membership
IMPACT+ Membership
Close
Coaching & Implementation Services
Coaching & Implementation Services
Close

Services Overview

See how you can dramatically increase your inbound leads and sales.

Services Overview

Digital Sales and Marketing Mastery

Fast track your team’s success with IMPACT's most popular service.

Digital Sales and Marketing Mastery

Web Design

Launch a beautiful website that consistently generates leads and revenue.

Web Design

Virtual Sales Training

Equip your sales team with comprehensive training designed to help them close more deals in today's virtual-first world.

Virtual Sales Training

HubSpot Training & Implementation

Train your company to take ownership of HubSpot and get the most out of your investment.

HubSpot Training & Implementation

Case Studies

See dozens of examples of companies succeeding with Digital Sales and Marketing Mastery and They Ask, You Answer.

Case Studies
Become a Coach
Become a Coach
Close

Can Code Be Copyrighted? Google Takes Oracle to Court to Find Out.

Can Code Be Copyrighted? Google Takes Oracle to Court to Find Out. Blog Feature

Joel Waggener

UX Designer, Paid Media Specialist, 15+ Years of Print and Web Design Expertise

January 26th, 2019 min read

On the last leg of a nearly nine-year court journey, Google has asked the Supreme Court to hear their case against Oracle Corp.

The drama began in 2010 when Oracle filed suit against Google for using Oracle-owned application program interfaces (APIs) in its Android operating system on mobile devices.

Oracle claims Google’s use of their APIs was a violation of copyright law.

Meanwhile, Google has argued that APIs are too fundamental in the programming world to be copyrighted -- raising many questions and concerns for developers, marketers, and brands alike.
This isn’t the first time Google has petitioned the Supreme Court. Google asked for a hearing in 2014, but the Court rejected the request at the time.

Over the years, both companies have won, lost, and appealed to lower courts’ decisions.

In 2016, Google briefly won a decision by a federal jury in San Francisco.

They ruled it didn't infringe on Oracle's intellectual property when building Android, but of course, Oracle appealed and a circuit court reversed the jury's decision.

Google could stand to owe $8.8 Billion to Oracle.

Why All the Fuss Over APIs?

APIs work across different devices and provide the instructions for things like connecting to the internet or accessing certain types of files.

Programmers use APIs so they don’t have to write new code from scratch for every function in their software or change it for every device.

Kent Walker, SVP Of Global Affairs & Chief Legal Officer for Google argues:

“We built Android following the computer industry’s long-accepted practice of re-using software interfaces, which provide sets of commands that make it easy to implement common functionality—in the same way that computer keyboard short-cuts like pressing “control” and “p” make it easy to print. Android created a transformative new platform, while letting millions of Java programmers use their existing skills to create new applications.”

However, Oracle ain’t hearing it.

Oracle Executive Vice President and General Counsel Dorian Daley stated:

“The fabricated concern about innovation hides Google’s true concern: that it be allowed the unfettered ability to copy the original and valuable work of others for substantial financial gain. In major victories for software innovation, the Court of Appeals has twice sided with Oracle against Google. The Supreme Court should once again deny Google’s request to take the case.”

What the Final Decision Means for Software Companies and Developers

Wherever you stand on the case, the decision will have some complicated consequences for software companies and developers.

Tim Ostheimer, IMPACT Senior Front-end Developer says:

"Technology relies on the continual experimentation of developers and often their products rely on third-party applications and services, especially Google's and Oracle's. I'd hate to see this end up making independent developers and smaller companies scared of using APIs that require licensing or result in open source code no longer truly being open source. However, I completely understand that companies need to profit from their products and not everything can be free to use."

Daniel Escardo, IMPACT Front-end Developer:

“Development of any piece of software is the result of countless hours of “blood, sweat and tears”, trial and error, frustration, collaboration, etc. For those developers / teams that go out of their way to make their software free for use in any way shape or form — god bless them. But those that expect to receive remuneration for their efforts should be considered. I think the Supreme Court’s ruling determined that Google overused the software and that Oracle (through its ownership of Java acquired through their purchase of Sun Microsystems) is entitled to something.”

Developers can clearly see both sides of the story.

Building off of each other’s code helps developers create faster and most likely better than they could on their own -- But at what cost for your own intellectual property? Possibly your entire product?

The battle for what open source will look like moving forward is coming to a head.

Depending on the outcome of this landmark case, the future of software development—and the apps and programs that so many of us have come to spend (way too many) hours a day using—could be greatly affected.

If your company creates and markets SaaS or software, keep your ear to the ground on this.

We may not see such rapid growth with programs that work in tandem or mutually benefit each other. I will be interested to see if the Supreme Court upholds the lower court’s decision. Stay tuned!

Want to learn more about digital sales and marketing?

Master digital sales and marketing when you join IMPACT+ for FREE. Gain instant access to exclusive courses and keynotes taught by Marcus Sheridan, Brian Halligan, Liz Moorehead, Ann Handley, David Cancel, Carina Duffy, Zach Basner, and more.

Sign up for free
Take a peek

Access hundreds of FREE courses and keynotes

Free Course
Digital Sales & Marketing Framework for Today’s Buyers
By: Marcus Sheridan
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
A New Way to Compete & Win
By: Brian Halligan
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Virtual Keynote
How To Genuinely Feel Confident, Be Likable, And Build Trust On Camera
By: Liz Moorehead
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
The Future of Marketing is Conversational​
By: David Cancel
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Deep Dive
HubSpot On a Budget: Getting Started with HubSpot Starter Hubs
By: Courtney Caldwell
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Assignment Selling: Content is Your Greatest Sales Tool
By: Marcus Sheridan
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
The Big, Bold, Brave New World of Marketing​
By: Ann Handley
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Investing in Incredible Digital Sales and Marketing Results
By: Chris Duprey
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
How To Show Your Content Makes Money With HubSpot Marketing and Sales Hubs
By: Liz Moorehead
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Virtual Keynote
The Visual Sale
By: Marcus Sheridan & Tyler Lessard
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
Marketing Tech: What’s Now, What’s Near and What’s Not Anytime Soon?​
By: Dharmesh Shah
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Inbound Lead Generation & Conversion Optimization
By: Carina Duffy
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Virtual Keynote
Fundamentals of Videography: You Can Be a Great Videographer Too
By: Zach Basner
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Deep Dive
The Ultimate Customer Service Toolkit for Any Budget
By: Andriti Gulati
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
6 Topics Subject Matter Experts Need to Address
By: Kevin Phillips
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
Fanocracy: The Power of Making Business Personal​
By: David Meerman Scott
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
The Power of Pillar Content
By: Liz Moorehead
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
SEO for the Future
By: Franco Valentino
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Fundamentals of Social Media Marketing
By: Stephanie Baiocchi
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Deep Dive
A Practical Guide To Video Graphics
By: Colton Trcic
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Session
How To Get Your Community To Know, Like, And Trust You With Video
By: Marki Lemons Rhyal
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Video Sales and Marketing Strategy
By: Zach Basner
View Course Preview View Course Preview
IMPACT+ Sign Up
A FREE online learning community with on-demand courses, hundreds of expert-led sessions, thousands of your peers ready to support you, and much more.
Check it out
Hundreds of courses and recorded keynotes, completely FREE
Check it out
Access hundreds of digital sales and marketing courses and recorded keynotes, completely FREE