Join the IMPACT coaches for a deep dive on a new topic every month in our free virtual event series.

Register Here

Join the IMPACT coaches for a deep dive on a new topic every month in our free virtual event series.
Register Here
The Ultimate Inbound Marketing Strategy Playbook 2022

Take your inbound strategy to the next level

  • Master the 7 principles of highly effective inbound marketing
  • Dramatically improve your inbound sales
  • Get more buy-in at your company

What Goes On a Marketing Scorecard? Evaluating Marketing KPIs & More

By Bob Ruffolo

What Goes On a Marketing Scorecard? Evaluating Marketing KPIs & More

what-goes-on-a-marketing-scorecardAre you effectively measuring your Inbound Marketing ROI?

Without a Marketing Scorecard, there's a good chance that your business has no idea where your Marketing budget is best spent.

You also can't be sure which Marketing tactics are working and which aren't, unless you are keeping score.

Most Marketers already understand the value that comes with having a Marketing scorecard, but maybe you're not sure what exactly goes on it. 

Marketers all too often make the mistake of thinking that revenue is the only measurement a business needs to assess its Marketing effectiveness.

The problem with this is that it fails to directly address issues that occur at different points in the Marketing funnel well before prospects are even converted into leads. 

 Join the IMPACT coaches for a deep dive on a new topic every month in our free virtual event series.

Plus, it doesn't give you a clear picture of where exactly that growth in revenue is coming from.

One of the biggest advantages of Inbound Marketing over traditional advertising methods is your ability to track and measure every little detail. Not only that, but you get feedback in real-time, instead of having to wait weeks or months for any indication of how your Marketing is performing.

That said, Inbound Marketing does take time and you can't expect results immediately. It is all about getting bigger results that sustain themselves over the long-term, not short spikes in growth that fizzle out and disappear forever.

To ensure you are doing everything you can to get that sustainable growth, you want to start keeping score of your marketing today and this article is going to show you how to do it.

Pick a Primary Objective for Your Marketing Scorecard

Before you can determine how you will score everything, you have to decide on a primary Marketing objective.

All of these things will be goals for your company, but you'll need to select one as your primary focus for any given period of time to be able to properly assess your Marketing score.

These are the primary Marketing goals of most businesses:

  • Brand Awareness: The amount of people you reach by creating content, being found on search engines, and your social media presence.
  • Lead Generation: Converting blog readers and social media followers into qualified leads that you nurture through email Marketing campaigns and by providing premium content.
  • Sales: Turning qualified leads into customers by optimizing sales pages, email campaigns, and the process your sales team uses.
  • Customer Loyalty: Maintaining loyal customers by providing useful content for them (as well as prospects) and creating additional products or services that add more value.

The area of your Marketing funnel that is the weakest is most likely the area that needs a scoring system first because you don't want any weak links in your Marketing chain.

Businesses tend to have strong and weak areas of their business that coincide with the strengths of their team, so while you might find it very easy to close sales, that strength is forever limited to your ability to generate leads.

Identify Your Top Marketing KPIs

KPIs, or key performance indicators, are the actual metrics that you will measure to assess the performance of your Marketing efforts based on your primary objective.

The most important KPIs are relative to your primary objective, which is why you did that first.

Top KPIs Based on Your Primary Marketing Objective

Brand Awareness:

  • Website visitors
  • Pageviews
  • Referral traffic
  • Bounce rate
  • Time on site
  • Social shares
  • Inbound links
  • Blog comments
  • Social reach
  • Video views/Podcast plays
  • Email subscribers
  • Ungated content downloads
  • Keyword ranking

Lead Generation:

  • Gated content downloads
  • Webinar registrations
  • Event attendance
  • Conversion rate
  • Marketing-qualified leads (MQLs)
  • Sales-qualified leads (SQLs)
  • Average lead quality score


  • Total new customers
  • Conversion rate
  • Top-converting pages
  • Content asset ROI
  • Average cost of customer acquisition

Customer Loyalty:

  • Social sharing
  • Reviews or survey results
  • Newsletter subscribers
  • Product or service upsells
  • Email forwards and click through rate (CTR)
  • Customer lifetime value (CLV)

Those aren't the only KPIs, they are just some of the most common ones. Also, you don't have to focus on improving every single KPI for your primary objective. In fact, you're better off staying highly focused on improving only a few of these at a time.

Marketing Assessment and Strategy Creation

Taylor Radey explained it perfectly when she described how to perform a Marketing assessment by analyzing your foundation, platform, expectations, and potential.

  • Foundation: What are the strengths of your current website? How deep is your content asset library? What is your brand image? What is the primary strength of your business model? What advantages do you have from your Marketing technology? What are the strengths of your team and processes? How much building work needs to be done to have a solid foundation?
  • Platform: How extensive is your reach on social media? Do you rely on paid advertising or do you have a large following of engaged fans that share your content? How influential is your brand among prospects, leads, and customers? Are you viewed as an authority or thought leader in your industry? Is your brand easy to find on Google when searching relevant keywords?
  • Expectations: What are your most important needs and goals currently? How do those goals align with your available talent, technologies, and other resources? Do you have realistic expectations for growth?
  • Potential: Based on your current assets and the effort required to improve weak areas of your Marketing funnel, what is the potential for success in the short-term and long-term?

The goal here is to align your primary objective and top KPIs with the Marketing strategy that makes the most sense, based on an assessment of your current situation. Again, we aren't simply tracking everything because we know that it's important to do. All of our Marketing efforts have a clear purpose.

Create Your Scorecard

First you want to gather up your KPIs from the various tracking tools you're using (Google Analytics, HubSpot, etc).

Create an Excel or Google spreadsheet to track your data or use software such as Marketing Score (as pictured below). You'll want to list your goals and KPIs for each goal, along with their priorities.

Try to fill in monthly performance for the previous year, or as far back as you have data, that way you have benchmarks for comparison. Be sure to note any important events, whether seasonal or industry-related, that could have a significant impact on your KPIs for a given time period.



Then you want to create a column or row for your goals and track your progress towards those goals as a percentage.



Once you've taken the time to get everything setup, all you have to do is import new data each month. From now on you'll have a Marketing scorecard that you can use to track your performance and identify the strengths and weaknesses in your Marketing funnel.

Join the IMPACT coaches for a deep dive on a new topic every month in our free virtual event series.


Reporting & Performance
Published on October 2, 2015

Recent Articles

Vanity Metrics Are The Most Misunderstood Numbers in Marketing
December 26, 2022 • 4 min read
What Marketers Need To Know About Switching to GA4 [Google Analytics 4]
July 30, 2022 • 5 min read
13 Valuable Marketing KPI Dashboards To Track Every Metric That Matters
July 14, 2022 • 8 min read
Get More Out of HubSpot Reporting With a Third-party Tool
July 9, 2022 • 5 min read
Databox vs. Geckoboard: Choosing the Right Data Platform for You
July 2, 2022 • 7 min read
10 Marketing KPIs You Should Be Tracking
March 3, 2022 • 9 min read
Google Shares New Tools to Audit Website User Experience
August 12, 2021 • 3 min read
8 Best Digital Marketing Tools and Tech for Every Business (+ VIDEO)
March 31, 2021 • 7 min read
10 Google Analytics metrics you absolutely must track (updated)
March 29, 2021 • 5 min read
Google Analytics 4: Your business website analytics are now smarter
November 11, 2020 • 3 min read
Why a growth-driven design website will give you better traffic, leads, and sales
October 26, 2020 • 5 min read
Social Media KPIs: The 10 You Really Should Be Tracking and Monitoring
August 30, 2020 • 6 min read
Content ROI Examples: How to Nail Your Reporting Strategy with HubSpot
August 28, 2020 • 12 min read
How to Create a Powerful Monthly Content Marketing ROI Newsletter
August 7, 2020 • 6 min read
Google Analytics to offer 2 new probability metrics: purchase and churn
July 20, 2020 • 2 min read
Data privacy update: How the CCPA affects you and your paid advertising
July 15, 2020 • 4 min read
How attribution reporting helped iCIMS improve its Google Ads performance ft. Joel Maldonado of Path Interactive (Inbound Success, Ep. 150)
July 6, 2020 • 18 min read
What does Basecamp’s privacy-focused HEY email service mean for marketers? [IMPACT Toolbox June 2020]
June 25, 2020 • 5 min read
Google Ads now offers category reporting for your Search and Shopping ads
June 1, 2020 • 2 min read
How to Measure Content Marketing ROI, Celebrate Your Wins, and Keep Your Job
April 16, 2020 • 7 min read
Case study: Are you confident in the data behind your digital marketing strategy?
March 24, 2020 • 7 min read
Google makes it easier to hide content and check third-party reporting
February 4, 2020 • 3 min read
RIP HubSpot's 'links' tool: What you should use instead
January 8, 2020 • 3 min read
Why do regular backups of your website matter?
December 23, 2019 • 6 min read
What is Google Analytics? The pros, cons, and ugly missing link
December 17, 2019 • 10 min read