4 Questions for Defining a Winning Value Proposition
- What exactly do you do?
- Who is your target audience?
- What are your audience's pain points?
- How will your product or service remedy these issues?
Originally written by John Becker. Updated by Bob Ruffolo with support from the IMPACT editorial team.
Last updated: November 2, 2026
Think back to when you last fell in love with a business.
Maybe you were on their homepage, or browsing their social profiles. They said something interesting, so you stopped scrolling. You thought, “This is exactly what I’m looking for. They get me.” Everything just clicked.
It probably sounded something like: “We sell the best widgets at a low cost to anyone with a wallet.”
Actually, probably not.
Too many companies fall into that trap, though. It’s the look how great we are trap, where the copy is all about the company. That doesn’t work, and honestly, maybe it never did. It doesn’t show potential customers how you can help them.
That’s why your value proposition is so important.
What is a value proposition?
Your value proposition is a statement that clearly defines what you do and how you help people. It captures what sets your business apart from everyone else, and it helps guide your potential customer’s decision-making process.
In short, it’s your first stage of conversion.
Value props are pithy and to the point. It’s not a time to go on and on. If you’d like to see how other companies handle this, browse these value proposition examples.
If your potential customers don’t see their needs reflected in your value proposition, they’ll go elsewhere.
That’s why a value proposition isn’t easy to pin down. It’s also not something AI can write for you from scratch. AI tools can help you draft options and pressure-test your wording, but only after you’ve done the work of understanding what you do best and what your customers need.
These four questions will help you define what makes your business unique and what resonates with your potential customers.
1. What exactly do you do?
Your value proposition will probably end up on your homepage or in prominent places throughout your website.
After reading it, someone should have a good idea of what you do and how you can help them (if they’re a fit). If they have to go digging to get that high-level view, your value proposition needs to be clearer.
Start with your industry. Are you in the marketing industry, the restaurant industry, the roofing industry?
Within your industry, what is your expertise? What sets you apart from your competitors?
To develop a strong value proposition, you must be able to clearly and confidently define what your company does and how you do it differently than the rest of the businesses in your niche.
If you’re struggling here, start writing what we call The Big 5: content that answers buyers’ questions about cost, problems, comparisons, reviews, and the best options in your space. Writing it will help you think through what’s unique about your business, including how you solve problems, how you compare to your competitors, and how you treat your customers.
2. Who is your target audience?
This question is twofold: Who do you want your audience to be? And who is actually buying from you?
It’s easy for marketers to come up with a grand set of personas based on who they think the company is selling to. What matters more is who is actually buying from your business.
Work with your sales team to get a thorough understanding of this.
Salespeople will know what’s resonating with your customers, what their biggest pains are, and who they’re going with if they don’t buy from you.
If you haven’t already, consider bringing marketing, sales, and service together as a revenue team, so you get a full picture of your marketing efforts and what your audience is actually responding to.
If your sales team uses Assignment Selling, sharing specific articles and videos with prospects before sales conversations so they arrive informed, look at which content prospects consume most. Does anything seem misaligned with who your target audience is, or does it support what you’re proposing? Use this information to check whether you’re heading in the right direction.
3. What are your audience’s pain points?
While you’re working with your sales team, dig deeper into your customers’ pain points with them as well. This is where you’ll find the key to a powerful value proposition.
What makes your offering valuable is that it actually solves a problem for your audience. Without that, they’ll find a more compelling option elsewhere. So, ask your sales team what’s keeping your buyers up at night.
Better yet, ask them to identify existing clients they would love to see more of. These are the people you’ll want to learn more about.
If possible, set up an interview with these clients. During the interview, your main focus should be uncovering the challenges they’re facing.
Let the conversation unfold naturally, and avoid diving in headfirst. Try not to lead the conversation, because you want to hear new things and shed new light on what you already know. If you give clients a chance to talk, they may reveal things you wouldn’t have uncovered through a more structured interview.
If you need a few talking points, consider these questions:
- What do you see as your biggest challenges so far?
- Is your business fulfilling its purpose? Why or why not?
- Is timing or funding a factor in achieving the success you want to reach?
- Can your customers hear you? How do you know?
Aim to find out whether their problem is unavoidable, urgent, or underserved. That tells you how much the problem matters to them and how clearly your value proposition needs to show that you can solve it.
Many of these conversations will happen over video calls. With the client’s permission, record them so you can go back to their exact words when you start writing.
4. How will your product or service remedy these issues?
Think about the products or services you’ve bought lately.
Almost everything we buy serves a purpose, because products and services are designed to solve the problems we have, including problems we didn’t know we had.
Take a step back and look at your products or services in terms of solutions. What types of problems can they solve?
Once you understand how your products or services can remedy your target audience’s pain points, you can begin to present that in your value proposition.
Position your product or service as the answer to the problems you heard about in those conversations, and be honest about what it costs buyers to leave those problems unsolved.
What’s next?
This is a good start, but your work isn’t over once you’ve identified how you can remedy your buyers’ problems. Next, turn what you’ve learned into copy that resonates, and keep looking for gaps in your messaging.
Keep talking to customers, testing drafts with your sales team, and refining your ideas until you keep coming back to the same clear statement. Then put it where buyers will see it first, starting with your homepage.
Order Your Copy of Marcus Sheridan's New Book — Endless Customers!