Learn
Learn
Close

What is 'They Ask, You Answer'?

A revolutionary approach to driving more sales from your inbound marketing.

Learn MoreLearn More

Free Courses in IMPACT+

Dozens of sales, marketing, and content courses inside IMPACT+. Start learning now.

See all coursesSee all courses
Events
Events
Close
IMPACT+ Membership
IMPACT+ Membership
Close
Services
Services
Close

Services Overview

See how you can dramatically increase your inbound leads and sales.

Services Overview

Digital Sales and Marketing Mastery

Fast track your team’s success with IMPACT's most popular service.

Digital Sales and Marketing Mastery

Web Design

Launch a beautiful website that consistently generates leads and revenue.

Web Design

Virtual Sales Training

Equip your sales team with comprehensive training designed to help them close more deals in today's virtual-first world.

Virtual Sales Training

HubSpot Training & Implementation

Train your company to take ownership of HubSpot and get the most out of your investment.

HubSpot Training & Implementation

Case Studies

See dozens of examples of companies succeeding with Digital Sales and Marketing Mastery and They Ask, You Answer.

Case Studies
Become a Certified Coach
Become a Certified Coach
Close

New Senate Bill Aims to Protect Users from "Dark Pattern" Design Practices

New Senate Bill Aims to Protect Users from "Dark Pattern" Design Practices Blog Feature

April 10th, 2019 min read

It’s no secret that well-designed websites or ads can help “push” users into taking desired actions. There have also been multiple studies on psychological marketing practices that can influence the way we buy. Things like color theory in ad design, CTA buttons that will prompt an emotional reaction and other tactics have become staples in strategies that (we hope) will influence our target audience.

But what happens when the line between consumer behavior and consumer manipulation becomes blurred?

On Tuesday, U.S. Senators Mark Warner and Deb Fischer introduced a piece of bipartisan legislation that aims to protect people from questionable design practices that intentionally mislead users.

The bill, which they’re calling “Deceptive Experiences to Online Users Reduction” Act, or DETOUR for short, will make it illegal to utilize “dark pattern” design tactics or “relying on user interfaces that intentionally impair user autonomy, decision-making, or choice.”

Before you panic, if passed, the bill will only apply to websites with more than 100 million active monthly users - so this is specifically targeted towards the top tech companies with the most influence.

Still, it’s important for marketers and designers to understand the difference between a clever design strategy and manipulative tactics.

What Are “Dark Patterns”?

A “Dark Pattern” refers to “features of interface design crafted to trick users into doing things they might not want to do, but which benefit the business in question”.

Common examples of this include:

  • Intentionally placing what looks like a smudge or hair on an ad to trick users into clicking
  • Pre-checking boxes for consent
  • Designing your website to be purposely confusing so it's difficult for a user to modify or cancel a subscription (think the IKEA store setup for websites)
  • Using misleading buttons to intentionally trick users into unwanted actions (like popup ads that show an “X” that makes it look like you can close out of it, but really it leads to a company’s website)

The term “dark patterns” is relatively new. It was coined in 2010 by design researcher and cognitive scientist Harry Brignull. Brignull actually has an entire website dedicated to spreading awareness of dark patterns that includes different types of dark pattern practices, and even a “Hall of Shame” for particularly bad offenders.

Here’s a short video that covers more about what dark patterns are, and notable examples from top companies:

Dark patterns are annoying at best, and downright harmful at worst.

Senator Warner also offered several more examples of dark pattern practices in a lengthy Twitter thread this week.

In it, he made it clear that while these tactics may seem harmless at first, they can (and have) been used to trick us into sharing data we may not have consented to otherwise:

“Some of these #DarkPatterns, like the fake hairs, may just cause some minor inconvenience. But too often, large social media platforms have relied on all sorts of tricks to convince users to hand over their personal data without really understanding what they are consenting to.”

“Case in point: privacy settings that push users to ‘agree’ as the default option, while users looking for more privacy-friendly options often must click through a much longer process, detouring through multiple screens.”

“These design tactics, drawn from extensive behavioral psychology research, are frequently used by social media platforms to mislead consumers into agreeing to settings and practices advantageous to the company.”

In a world where more and more of our personal data is online, it’s important for users to be well-informed on what they’re agreeing to, and not be mislead.

What Does DETOUR Propose?

At its core, the DETOUR Act is meant to create stricter regulations for exploitive and deceptive practices and demand more transparency from large, influential companies.

DETOUR breaks this into three distinct areas:

  • Eliminate misleading designs - the bill will make it unlawful for companies to “design, modify, or manipulate a user interface with the purpose or substantial effect of obscuring, subverting, or impairing user autonomy, decision-making, or choice to obtain consent or user data.”
  • Conduct behavioral experiments without informed consent - This means that companies will need to let you know about any of your data that is being used for behavioral experiments on the platform. Additionally, the bill would require organizations to  “establish an Independent Review Board for any behavioral or psychological research, of any purpose, conducted on users or on the basis of user activity or data, which shall review and have authority to approve, require modification in, or disapprove all behavioral or psychological experiments or research.”
  • Prohibit user interface designs that cultivate “compulsive usage” in children - Compulsive usage refers to “any response stimulated by external factors that cause an individual to engage in repetitive, purposeful, and intentional behavior causing psychological distress, loss of control, anxiety, depression, or harmful stress responses.” This would be specific to any of these tactics aimed at children younger than 13.

You can view the full text of the legislation here.  

The Future of Responsible Marketing

A good marketer should know that “tricking” your customer will rarely yield positive results for your bottom line or your reputation.

With this new proposed legislation, not only is this tactic ineffective, it also may soon be illegal.

There are many psychological marketing tactics out there, both on and offline, that are intended to impact behavior.

Most of these are relatively harmless - like using orange or red CTAs to promote a sense of urgency, or how grocery stores place their milk and eggs in the back of the store, so you’ll see more you want to buy on the way.

However, when it comes to companies intentionally misleading users to take actions they otherwise wouldn’t, this is where it starts to become less of a “tactic” and closer to a straight-up scam.

While this bill is only proposed for high-traffic companies, it’s important for marketers to take a look at their own strategies and ask if they’re truly putting the customer’s needs first.

If you’re consistently catering to your customers' needs, pain points, and goals, you won’t have to trick them - they’ll opt-in all on their own.

Want to learn more about digital sales and marketing?

Master digital sales and marketing when you join IMPACT+ for FREE. Gain instant access to exclusive courses and keynotes taught by Marcus Sheridan, Brian Halligan, Liz Moorehead, Ann Handley, David Cancel, Carina Duffy, Zach Basner, and more.

Sign up for free
Take a peek

Access hundreds of FREE courses and keynotes

Free Course
Digital Sales & Marketing Framework for Today’s Buyers
By: Marcus Sheridan
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
A New Way to Compete & Win
By: Brian Halligan
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Virtual Keynote
How To Genuinely Feel Confident, Be Likable, And Build Trust On Camera
By: Liz Moorehead
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
The Future of Marketing is Conversational​
By: David Cancel
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Deep Dive
HubSpot On a Budget: Getting Started with HubSpot Starter Hubs
By: Courtney Caldwell
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Assignment Selling: Content is Your Greatest Sales Tool
By: Marcus Sheridan
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
The Big, Bold, Brave New World of Marketing​
By: Ann Handley
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Investing in Incredible Digital Sales and Marketing Results
By: Chris Duprey
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
How To Show Your Content Makes Money With HubSpot Marketing and Sales Hubs
By: Liz Moorehead
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Virtual Keynote
The Visual Sale
By: Marcus Sheridan & Tyler Lessard
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
Marketing Tech: What’s Now, What’s Near and What’s Not Anytime Soon?​
By: Dharmesh Shah
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Inbound Lead Generation & Conversion Optimization
By: Carina Duffy
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Virtual Keynote
Fundamentals of Videography: You Can Be a Great Videographer Too
By: Zach Basner
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Deep Dive
The Ultimate Customer Service Toolkit for Any Budget
By: Andriti Gulati
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
6 Topics Subject Matter Experts Need to Address
By: Kevin Phillips
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
Fanocracy: The Power of Making Business Personal​
By: David Meerman Scott
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
The Power of Pillar Content
By: Liz Moorehead
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Keynote
SEO for the Future
By: Franco Valentino
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Fundamentals of Social Media Marketing
By: Stephanie Baiocchi
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Deep Dive
A Practical Guide To Video Graphics
By: Colton Trcic
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Session
How To Get Your Community To Know, Like, And Trust You With Video
By: Marki Lemons Rhyal
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Free Course
Video Sales and Marketing Strategy
By: Zach Basner
View Course Preview View Course Preview
Here Are Some Related Articles You May Find Interesting

Want to Contribute Content to impactplus.com? Click Here.

IMPACT+ Sign Up
A FREE online learning community with on-demand courses, hundreds of expert-led sessions, thousands of your peers ready to support you, and much more.
Check it out
The tools, education, and community you
need to master They Ask, You Answer.
Check it out
The tools, education, and community you need to master They Ask, You Answer.