Back to Learning Center
Subscribe
Join 40,000+ sales and marketing pros who receive our weekly insights, tips, and best practices.
Thank you! You have been subscribed.
Learning Center
Learning Center
Close
The IMPACT Learning Center

Free resources to help you master inbound marketing and They Ask, You Answer

Access the Learning Center

Access the Learning Center

Access the Learning Center
learning_center_grey__What is They Ask, You Answer-v2-black

What is They Ask, You Answer

What is <span>They Ask, You Answer</span>
Articles, Podcasts, & Updates

Articles, Podcasts, & Updates

Articles, Podcasts, <span>& Updates</span>
Free Courses & Certifications

Free Courses & Certifications

Free Courses & <span>Certifications</span>
On-Demand Keynotes & Sessions

On-Demand Keynotes & Sessions

On-Demand <span>Keynotes & Sessions</span>
Events
Events
Close
IMPACT+ Membership
IMPACT+ Membership
Close
Services
Services
Close
Navigation_8_2021_taya

They Ask, You Answer Coaching & Training

They Ask, You Answer Coaching & Training
They Ask, You Answer Workshop

They Ask, You Answer Workshop

They Ask, You Answer Workshop
Navigation_8_2021_workshop

Inbound Marketing Services

Inbound Marketing Services
Navigation_8_2021_website design - monitor

Website Design & Development

Website Design & Development
Navigation_8_2021_hubspot implementation

HubSpot Training & Implementation

HubSpot Training & Implementation
Navigation_8_2021_virtual selling

Virtual Sales
Training

Virtual Sales <br>Training
Navigation_8_2021_swell - paid ads

Paid Search & Social Services

Paid Search & Social Services
Become a Certified Coach
Become a Certified Coach
Close
Paid Media

Paid Search Piggyback: The Keyword Lessons of Edible Arrangements v. Google

By Jason Linde

Paid Search Piggyback: The Keyword Lessons of Edible Arrangements v. Google Blog Feature

Something very interesting happened in the search marketing space this past month and it most certainly caught my eye.

Google was hit with a $209 million lawsuit from Edible Arrangements for allegedly duping consumers searching for the term “Edible Arrangements.”

Rather than showing users what Edible Arrangements says is “customary information about their business” that would traditionally appear to the right of the top-most search results, Edible claims Google has been showing competitors’ ads.

The company insists consumers were misled into making a brand “connection” between them and other competitors’ products -- and needless to say Edible Arrangements wasn’t happy about it.

Now, before we get into the nitty-gritty, let me pause here and explain; this is not a case of what we in the marketing world know as traditional “piggyback” marketing, where two or more companies with non-competing products team up and form a marketing plan that is mutually beneficial (i.e. a Wedding Planner and a Video Photographer).

Instead, this lawsuit is about one company literally “piggybacking” on a competitor’s branded keywords and brand recognition to gain better positioning, and in some cases, stealing potential customers.

Not sure if it sounds sneaky or strategic? Well, that’s the grey area that makes this a tricky topic for marketers at organizations of all sizes, including yours.

Here’s what you need to know and what you can learn from this latest lawsuit.  

Friendly Rivalry or Cut-throat Competition?

According to Edible Arrangements, competitors using their branded keywords in paid search advertising has led to a massive loss; $200 million dollars in sales and approximately $9 million profit, to be exact.

-- And this is not the first time something like this has been the focal point of a lawsuit.

In 2010, a North Carolina court ruled in favor of an attorney whose name was used in a paid search campaign by another stating that this “cut-throat tactic” is a violation of the state’s Rules of Professional Conduct 8.4(c)*.

On the other hand, However, in a very similar case in a Texas court, it was ruled to allow competitive keyword advertising and not punish those who use it.

Google’s Stand on Competitive Keyword Advertising

Clearly, courts aren’t agreeing on the matter, but where does Google stand on the topic of competitive keyword advertising?

Unfortunately, at the moment, that’s just as unclear.  

Google does restrict the use of trademark terms (when disputed by brands), but currently, it has no protection for things like “Edible Arrangements” which is both a brand and a non-branded keyword used to describe what a person may intend to search for.

(It’s an issue anthimeria really, but that’s a talk for a whole different article.)

Note: While we are on the topic of trademarks, if you are advertising on  Google and want to be protected by their Trademark policy, I suggest that you take a few minutes to fill out the Trademark Complaint Form.  This will prevent a situation like Edible Arrangements’ from happening to you.

If you intend to market using a trademark that is not yours, then I recommend you fill out Google’s Trademark Authorization Form. (This would cover advertising for brands that are not your own).

Google’s methodical delay in responding to allegations like those from Edible Arrangements has the search marketing industry captivated.

The outcome of this lawsuit could potentially affect hundreds of thousands of advertisers and Google wants to ensure it has its ducks in a row and is ready to defend itself and its advertisers in court.

So, What Are The Possible Outcomes?

Thinking about the two possible outcomes here presents an interesting predicament.

If Google wins, there is potential for the floodgates to open and for competitive keyword advertising to become the norm.

Every business in a competitive space will no longer have to think twice about implementing a competitive keyword strategic marketing tactic. It will be a necessity in all verticals.

For example, if you are an up-and-coming SaaS company whose name is not quite well known yet, but believe your product can rival the best in the industry. You could build out a strategy where you move some of your AdWords budget into a campaign targeted at bidding on your competitor’s keywords directly (example: Salesforce).

Your Ads would speak to why the user who intended to find Salesforce would want to consider trying your product instead.

On the contrary, if Google settles with Edible Arrangements, a whole new can of worms could be opened and many more lawsuits could follow from companies.   

This is certainly a tough place for Google to be in. I am looking forward to following this story as it’s outcome could be a game-changers for search marketers and Google advertisers alike.

What Does This Mean for You?

1. Protect Your Brand

Until this lawsuit is settled, the playing field is wide open. There is nothing stopping your competitors from bidding on your brand’s keywords (or name for that matter) and their ads showing up when your potential customers search for you.

My advice is to dedicate ad spend to bidding on your own branded terms to ensure you hold your own in this space.

2. Know Your Competitors

Take a few minutes to Google yourself (often) to see who your paid search competitors are and take note of who is bidding on your branded terms.

3. Understand Google’s Advertising Policies

The last thing you want to do is put yourself or a client’s advertising account in jeopardy. Take the time to read and understand what Google deems acceptable and what they do not. Google may not have policies about branded keywords right now -- but that could change quickly.

4. Don’t Let Your Strategy Go Stale

Your keywords strategy should always be adapting to your own business growth as well as your competitor’s.

If you are not keeping an eye on your keyword strategy after you initially roll it out, then you are doing it wrong. You will see shifts month to month, especially in highly competitive spaces. So stay committed!

In Conclusion

As we’ve learned, in situations like this one between Edible Arrangements’ and Google, things are not so cut-and-dry.

This wasn’t a case where a competitive brand was pretending to be Edible Arrangements, although the company would like for us all to believe that.

The particular keywords in question could both be conceived as branded and non-branded.

Think of it like this, if you owned a flower shop that sold chocolate-covered fruit bouquets or baskets, what keywords would you want to show for?

I would imagine “edible arrangements” would come to mind. It’s a perfect description of your product; A perfect use of a keyword that would certainly fall within a buyer's search intent.

So, should you be allowed to use this keyword to help sell your product or will Google view this as a branded keyword infraction and prevent your ad from showing?   

That indeed is the $209 million-dollar question.

I guess we will see soon enough as this plays out where Google stands on the situation and how we proceed when it comes to our keyword strategies.

Topics:

Paid Media
Published on March 20, 2018

Recent Articles

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for July 26, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on July 26, 2021
6 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for July 19, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on July 19, 2021
6 min read

Google: 'Here's how to prepare for the future private web'

By Liz Moorehead on July 16, 2021
4 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for July 12, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on July 12, 2021
5 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for July 6, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on July 6, 2021
5 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for June 28, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on June 28, 2021
6 min read

Google punts third-party cookie ban to 2023 for 'responsible planning'

By Liz Moorehead on June 25, 2021
6 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for June 21, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on June 21, 2021
5 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for June 14, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on June 14, 2021
6 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for June 7, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on June 7, 2021
6 min read

You can boost LinkedIn posts and promote events, marketers

By Liz Moorehead on May 28, 2021
3 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for May 24, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on May 24, 2021
6 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for May 17, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on May 17, 2021
5 min read

ICYMI: Digital marketing news update for May 10, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on May 10, 2021
6 min read

What Apple's iOS 14 updates mean for your paid media strategy ft. Tim Keen (Inbound Success, Ep. 192)

By Kathleen Booth on April 26, 2021
32 min read

Marketers, Facebook Analytics will be no more on June 30, 2021

By Liz Moorehead on April 2, 2021
2 min read

Facebook ads vs. boosted posts: Which is more effective in 2021?

By Ali Parmelee on March 23, 2021
3 min read

Google Ads help: Top 10 reasons your Google Ads campaigns are failing

By Jason Linde on March 10, 2021
10 min read

Free LinkedIn marketing and advertising learning center now live

By Nicole Letendre on March 1, 2021
2 min read

Google Ads vs Facebook Ads: Which is better for your 2021 ad strategy?

By John Becker on February 19, 2021
11 min read

Profit curve is key to your Google Ads strategy Ft. Mike Rhodes of WebSavvy (Inbound Success, Ep. 182)

By Kathleen Booth on February 15, 2021
36 min read

Working with IMPACT on paid media: What to expect

By John Becker on January 13, 2021
4 min read

Snapchat is betting big on Bitmoji fashion

By Rachel Palmateer on January 12, 2021
3 min read

Instagram advertisers can create branded content ads on creators’ accounts

By Justine Timoteo Thomas on January 6, 2021
2 min read

TikTok still available in the US despite not reaching a sell-off deal

By Karisa Egan on December 11, 2020
2 min read