When we were kids in school, we all learned from our parents (hopefully) that a lie of omission is still a lie.
Unfortunately, it would appear that Facebook still hasn’t gotten that memo.
“Uh Oh, What Did Facebook Do Now?”
In 2016, a group of advertisers filed a lawsuit in California, alleging Facebook provided falsified metrics and conducted unfair business practices by distributing inaccurate data.
This allegation was brought to light after Facebook had been accused of overestimating the traction of videos shown on their platform. At the time, Facebook admitted to inflating video viewing figures and taking a sample size of the “average viewing time” into their calculations.
By only using views of videos that lasted more than three seconds, however, their average viewing times per video were inflated by 60% to 80%.
In an additional filing from Tuesday (shown above), the plaintiffs have added a fraud claim, saying Facebook knew they were misleading advertisers an entire year before they disclosed this information.
Instead of owning up to their miscalculations, however, they continued to report on the inaccurate data and made no strides to remedy the situation internally or issue a public apology. They also tried to draw attention away from their error by retiring the “erroneous metrics” and replacing them with a net new metric: “Average Watch Time.”
The plaintiffs have a point here, but what’s even harder to swallow is that the claim stated that Facebook’s inflation was far worse than originally reported.
Instead of 60% to 80%, average viewership metrics had been inflated by 150% to even 900%. Talk about fuzzy math.
“Is This Really That Big of a Deal?”
Marketers and businesses live and die by data.
If we can’t tell how successful our campaigns actually are, how are we supposed to improve marketing tactics and strategies?
Plus, as the plaintiffs rightly point out, such an alleged gross misrepresentation of success incentivized advertisers to spend more on Facebook video advertisements -- since advertisers believing the average viewing time of these ads appeared much more lucrative than they actually were on average, they doubled down on their Facebook spend.
“Suggestions that we in any way tried to hide this issue from our partners are false."
We spend thousands of marketing dollars every day, expecting that the data we purchase is accurate. Data impacts all decisions around the way we sell, market and conduct our day-to-day business. If the data is wrong, then our strategies are wrong and so is our bottom line.
If they’re willing to half lie about this, does that mean there are other half-truths or lies about the data we rely upon lingering out there that we don’t know about?
“Are You Saying I Shouldn’t Do Business with Facebook?”
It’s really unfortunate that Facebook can’t seem to keep it together. And when these questionable practices are brought to light, it’s understandable that you might reconsider how you leverage Facebook as part of your marketing strategy..
That said, Facebook owned their original inflation mistake… at least in part. (Their internal PR strategy for acknowledging their math error could take some criticism.)
But in the grand scheme of things, how big of a faux pas was their half-truth?
Some marketers are arguing that the “average duration of videos viewed” metric does not determine a video’s success. It’s not a metric they actually use. Marketers are more concerned about reach, frequency, and the percentage of a video watched to determine a video’s success.
That said, isn’t the type of data in question here moot?
You can’t help but wonder if this is a red flag, a sign of a potential pattern of behavior, where they play fast and loose with the data we reply upon to make business decisions.
Today, it might be video plays. But tomorrow it might be something else.
Facebook has owned up to their half-truths (well, sort of) and are taking steps to remedy the issue. But we also need to be aware that data we rely upon from any platform -- Facebook or otherwise -- is not infallible. There is often a margin of error, even when the data is correct.
If you are doing business or are considering doing business with Facebook, our say is that you simply proceed with caution.
But remember, as the old saying goes, “Everybody deserves a second chance, but not for the same mistakes.”
Want to learn more about digital sales and marketing?
Master digital sales and marketing when you join IMPACT+ for FREE. Gain instant access to exclusive courses and keynotes taught by Marcus Sheridan, Brian Halligan, Liz Moorehead, Ann Handley, David Cancel, Carina Duffy, Zach Basner, and more.